On a train in pre-World War II Europe, American heiress Amanda Metcalfe Madvani von Hoffstetter Kelly (Cybill Shepherd) is bamboozled when her newest friend, Miss Froy (Angela Lansbury), disappears. As she struggles to discover what happened, she falls into camaraderie with Robert Condon (Elliott Gould), and the two work to discover what happened to Miss Froy.
The Lady Vanishes was directed by Anthony Page and is a fun mystery with a likable story and mostly enjoyable characters. Cybill Shepherd plays Amanda Metcalfe Madvani von Hoffstetter Kelly as a carefree young woman. Her character is developed quickly in the opening act as we see her make a foolish choice and then leave all her belongings behind in her rush to leave. As we discover more about her, it is just as well that the audience knows some of the truth about Miss Froy lest we join the other people on the train in their disbelief. Angela Lansbury is enjoyable, but her performance as Miss Froy is brief. The banter between Robert Condon’s character and Amanda is enjoyable, and Elliott Gould plays a likable character.

The mystery unfolding is enjoyable, despite Amanda taking a little too long to convince anyone of the truth. The time limit and containment of characters created by the train itself are even more enjoyable, leading to a sense of urgency and claustrophobic danger. This film has some enjoyable stunts, and the characters demonstrate their ‘humanness’ through their discomfort in these experiences. The enjoyable mystery is enhanced by the great set and costumes. While the pacing is a little difficult at times, the story unravels to a satisfying denouement and resolution for each character.

Overall, The Lady Vanishes is an enjoyable mystery set in pre-war Europe. With generally likeable characters—including the single-minded side characters—lovely costumes and a fun setting, this mystery takes its time before quickly unravelling to a slightly unexpected conclusion. The pacing was the main issue for me while watching, and the pacing was slowed by Amanda’s character spending too long protesting her rationality. Overall, it was an enjoyable watch.
5.5/10
20th April 2025
Written by Trisha Walkden



FOLLOW US ON LETTERBOXD:
@Peter_Walkden



THANK YOU FOR VISITING!
0 Comments